When the Patna High Court sends a dispute back to an officer with the words "consider the objections and pass a final order", it is giving the officer a task as well as a deadline. In Ravindra Kumar the residents of a Patna neighbourhood did exactly what the Court had told them to do in 2022: they filed objections. The order that followed in March 2024 declared their houses encroachments and never mentioned those objections. On 5 November 2026 Justice Alok Kumar held that silence on the objections vitiated the order, quashed it, and sent the case back for a reasoned decision after a proper hearing.
The second trip to the High Court
Two writ petitions were heard together. The first petitioners claimed portions of Plot No. 274 in Kankarbagh, Patna, one by a registered sale deed of 2015, the other by a joint holding mutated in 1982. Six residents in the second petition said they held registered deeds, jamabandis and rent receipts. The State's case, resting on a Circle Amin's measurement of the 90-feet road from Malahi Pakri towards NH-30, was that the structures stood on a public road.
- 19 Jan 2022: notice under s. 6(2) of the Bihar Public Land Encroachment Act, 1956 in Encroachment Case No. 07/2021-22
- 29 Nov 2022: CWJC No. 2080 of 2022 disposed of; the s. 6(2) notices are quashed, objections to be filed, Circle Officer to consider them and pass a final order under s. 6(1), status quo meanwhile
- 25 Jan 2024: fresh notice under s. 3(1); show-cause replies filed on 10 Feb 2024
- 5 Mar 2024: notice to remove the structures within 15 days, failing which penalty under s. 188 IPC; one set of petitioners was told to clear by 21 Mar 2024
- 19 Mar 2024: High Court records that no demolition is to be made while the petitions are pending
- 5 Nov 2026: judgment: the order of 5 March 2024 is quashed and the matter remanded
The petitioners argued that the s. 6 notice came without a proper s. 3 notice (a Patna High Court decision, Shailesh Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2019 (6) BLJ 96, was cited for the rule that the Form-1 notice must give at least two weeks to appear), despite the status quo order, and without the measurement report. They said title was in dispute and cited Rekha Singh v. State of Bihar (1992) and Hafiza Khatoon v. State of Bihar (1991), the latter for the proposition that the State must first show prima facie that the land is public. They also said their 12 March 2024 request for a certified copy, needed to appeal to the Collector, went unmet. The State replied that a final order had been passed after hearing them at length, that a notice to remove followed, and that the proper course was an appeal to the Collector.
The High Court decided none of those questions. It took one fact from the record, that the order "is silent on the objection filed by the petitioner", and found that enough.
Why a remand direction is a promise the order must keep
Paragraph 17 gives the reason for the result: the objections "were filed in the light of the order passed by a Coordinate Bench" and "the non-consideration of these objections vitiates the order". A court remand that says "consider the objections" does two things. It converts a pending administrative file into a matter with a defined step, and it makes that step checkable. An authority may reject every objection, but it must show that it read them.
That is also why the case is not merely a restatement of "give reasons". The authority here had been told once already by the High Court. The 2022 judgment had quashed the s. 6(2) removal notices precisely because the process was premature. To issue another removal notice in March 2024 that skipped the answer to the objections undid the work of the earlier writ.
The line above is the Court's paraphrase of Mahabir Prasad Santosh Kumar v. State of U.P. (1970) 1 SCC 764, one of a run of authorities the judgment strings together in paragraphs 18 to 22. The run begins with the 1960s: Harinagar Sugar Mills (AIR 1961 SC 1669) on reasons even in an administrative-looking decision, and Travancore Rayon (1969) 3 SCC 868 on why reasons matter, both to let the aggrieved person show the reasons are wrong and to restrain arbitrariness. Mohan Lal Capoor (1973) 2 SCC 836 treats reasons as the link between the material considered and the conclusion reached, Ram Chander (1986) 3 SCC 103 reads "consider" as requiring application of mind, and Kranti Associates (2010) 9 SCC 496 lists why reasons are "the soul of justice". These are the authorities as the High Court states them; they are cited in this article only as quoted in the judgment.
Where the Bihar Act's sections sit in the story
The judgment and the parties refer to three provisions of the Bihar Public Land Encroachment Act, 1956, and the order in which they are used shows how the Act is meant to run. Section 3 begins the process with a notice to the person said to have encroached to show cause. Section 6(1) is where the Circle Officer makes the final order after considering the cause shown. Section 6(2), the provision under which the notices quashed in 2022 were issued and under which the State says the 2024 notice was given, is the notice to remove the encroachment. On that reading the removal notice follows a final order, and the final order follows consideration of the answer. The 2024 notice failed on the middle step. We have not found a book in our library that sets the Bihar Act out section by section, so this sequence is taken from the way the judgment and the parties describe it; check the bare Act before you reproduce it in an exam. The Telangana chapter on eviction notice and hearing deals with the eviction procedure under a sister statute, which differs in its details, and the Telangana Judiciary Prelims 2020 paper asked whether an authority under such an Act follows the CPC, the Evidence Act and the rules or only the rules. The Patna Court calls proceedings under the Bihar Act "summary", and treats that as a reason to insist on reasons, not to excuse them.
One more link between old and new law. The notice threatened the occupants with "penalty under section 188 of the Indian Penal Code". That offence, disobedience to an order promulgated by a public servant, is now Section 223 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, as our notes on contempts of the lawful authority of public servants confirm.
Article 300A and Article 21 do the work of the closing paragraph
The petitioners pleaded Article 300A, which says that no person shall be deprived of property save by authority of law. Paragraph 24 takes that article and ties it to reasons: an order that lacks reasons, or shows no application of mind, "cannot legally deprive a person of their right to property under Article 300A, particularly when passed in a summary proceeding".
The Court also notes that the right to shelter is part of Article 21. It cites Zulfiquar Haider v. State of U.P., 2025 INSC 480, for the holding that homes cannot be demolished summarily without natural justice, a show-cause notice must be truly served, and the owner must have a real chance to show cause and to appeal. It also cites Rajeev Singh v. State of U.P., 2026 INSC 938, on lack of reasons showing non-application of mind. Both are as described by the Patna High Court, not independently verified. For the doctrinal frame, see our chapters on reasoned decisions and speaking orders, the components of the right to hearing and Article 21.
Why a writ was the right door and what certiorari did here
The State argued that an appeal lay to the Collector. The judgment does not discuss the point. Certiorari brings up the decision of an inferior authority and quashes it if it fails the test of legality, and a Circle Officer deciding under s. 6 whether land is public acts quasi-judicially. An alternative remedy is a matter of discretion under Article 226, not a bar. The Court does not say this in terms, but it is the footing for what it did. See the notes on writs as tools of administrative law.
What was left for the Circle Officer to decide again
- The Court did not decide whether the land is raiyati or public. It expressed no view on the khatian, rent receipts, or the Circle Amin's measurement. On remand those remain to be examined, and the State must still show prima facie that the land is public, as the petitioners argued with Hafiza Khatoon.
- The s. 3 notice period, the need for a prior s. 3 notice and the alleged breach of the status quo direction were not ruled on.
- Paragraph 25 asks for a "reasoned order after giving an adequate opportunity of hearing", but sets no timeline, and the judgment does not say what happens to the pending Encroachment Case No. 07/2021-22.
- The Court quashed the "order dated 05.03.2024", although the writ prayers had been aimed at the notice of that date. The petitioners' own claim that no order was ever supplied to them was not resolved either way.
For the Bihar Civil Judge paper: a summary statutory power runs only on the process the statute lays out, each step must show application of mind to what was said against it, and a court direction to consider objections makes that duty specific.
- dismiss the writ because an appeal lies to the Collector
- quash the order for non-consideration of objections and remit the matter for a reasoned order after hearing
- declare the land raiyati and restrain the State permanently
- direct the State to pay costs and refuse a remand
Answer
(b). The order vitiated by silence on the objections is quashed and remanded, as in Ravindra Kumar. The Court did not decide the title question, and the existence of an appeal did not stop it.
- It applies only to courts and not to administrative authorities
- It applies only where a statute expressly says that reasons must be recorded
- It is satisfied if a hearing is given, even if the order does not deal with the objections
- It applies to orders of quasi-judicial authorities and to administrative decisions that prejudice a person, and matters most in a summary proceeding where rights are affected
Answer
(d). Mere hearing is not enough, and reasons are required of quasi-judicial and prejudicial administrative decisions alike, as the Supreme Court authorities in the judgment (Mahabir Prasad, Kranti Associates) hold.
- Article 300A is a fundamental right that can be enforced only under Article 32
- A statute cannot authorise removal of encroachments from property that is claimed to be private
- An order that is cryptic and shows no application of mind cannot be the "authority of law" that deprives a person of property, particularly in a summary proceeding
- Compensation is payable on every removal of an encroachment
Answer
(c). Paragraph 24 links reasons, Article 300A and the summary character of the Act. The other options are not what the Court said.