On 29 September 2025 a customs team stopped a truck near Khowai in Tripura and held its occupants. The seizure of 60.79 kg of methamphetamine tablets was recorded as complete at 5 pm. The four men were shown as formally arrested at 11 am the next day and reached a Magistrate at 4.45 pm. On 5 November 2026 the Supreme Court said the arrest, for the purpose of Article 22(2), happened on the highway at 2 pm, so the 24 hours had run out two hours and forty-five minutes before the Magistrate saw them.
Twenty-one hours that the paperwork did not count
- 29 Sep 2025, 2.00 pm Truck intercepted; first seizure of 11.03 kg on the spot, field test, case registered.
- 29 Sep, about 5.00 pm Second seizure at the Customs Division office completed (60.79 kg in all).
- 30 Sep, 11.00 and 11.15 am Formal arrest under Section 42(1)(d) NDPS Act is recorded.
- 30 Sep, 4.45 pm Production before the Judicial Magistrate, who remands to judicial custody.
- 2 pm, 30 Sep The deadline the Supreme Court computed.
The point about the 24 hours had not been argued in the High Court of Tripura, which refused bail by leaning on the twin conditions of Section 37 NDPS Act. It surfaced at the Supreme Court hearing, and the Court called for an affidavit from the investigating officer. That affidavit is the heart of the case: it said the men were "intercepted" and not "detained" until the formal arrest, because the intervening hours went on notice under Section 50 NDPS Act, a gazetted officer, weighing, interrogation about the supply chain and travel.
The Additional Solicitor General added a fallback: even if the clock began when the search finished at 5 pm, production the next afternoon was within time. (He put production at 4.30 pm; the Court's findings say 4.45 pm.) He also relied on three High Court rulings and on Section 67 NDPS Act, which lets an officer examine a person during an enquiry.
Why "arrested and detained in custody" is one idea, not two
Article 22(2) says a person who is arrested and detained in custody must reach the nearest Magistrate within 24 hours, excluding the journey to the court, and cannot be kept longer without the Magistrate's authority. The Court noticed two textual facts. The clause uses "and", where Article 22(3) uses "or", so the words travel together. And the only deduction the Constitution allows is the journey time. Nothing in the text allows time for inventory, interrogation or a panchnama.
There is "no such thing" as a temporary disruption of liberty, and a buffer zone where the clock is switched off is, in the Court's words, unconstitutional.
That removed the argument that steps under the 2022 seizure Rules or Section 67 suspend the clock. Rule 3(4) requires weighing and packaging in the presence of the person from whom the drugs were recovered. Does that stop the officer from producing him before the Magistrate within 24 hours and finishing the formalities afterwards? The Court's answer was an emphatic no. Remand does not stop an investigation; it supervises it.
The second clock inside the first: Section 58 BNSS
The Court then turned to the statute that carries the constitutional rule. Section 57 CrPC, now Section 58 BNSS, forbids detaining a person arrested without warrant for longer than is reasonable in all the circumstances, and in any event beyond 24 hours without a special order of a Magistrate. Our chapter on arrest notes that the section caps police detention at 24 hours, exclusive of journey time, and that Section 187 BNSS (old Section 167 CrPC) is what lets a Magistrate authorise more.
Two limits sit in that one section. The first is the constitutional ceiling of 24 hours. The second is reasonableness inside it. The agency's own affidavit put the end of search and seizure at 5 pm on 29 September, yet it showed the arrests at 11 am the next day, and the Court recorded that no explanation was given for the 18-hour gap. Eighteen hours without judicial oversight, it said, cannot be a reasonable period. So there were two separate breaches: one of Article 22(2) and one of the statutory standard in Section 58 BNSS.
| Idea | Constitution | CrPC | BNSS |
|---|---|---|---|
| Produce before Magistrate within 24 hours; no longer detention without authority | Art. 22(2) | s.57 | s.58 |
| Magistrate's power when investigation cannot finish in 24 hours | - | s.167 | s.187 |
| Notice of appearance and arrest without warrant | - | ss.41, 41A | s.35 |
| How an arrest is made | - | s.46 | s.43 |
The last two rows are taken from the Court's own paragraphs on the old and new numbers. The correspondence table in our commentary shows the same pairing for the first two: BNSS 58 with CrPC 57, and BNSS 187 with CrPC 167.
Custody was never a matter of the label on the memo
The reasoning rests on an old line of authority. Niranjan Singh (Krishna Iyer J.), decided under Section 439 CrPC, held that a person is in custody when he is in the physical hold of an officer with coercive power, and called the gap between informal custody and formal arrest an "unfair evasion". Deepak Mahajan, as the Court reads it, treats a person as arrested once he is deprived of the liberty to go where he pleases. Our CrPC commentary also cites it for applying Section 167 to arrests under FERA and customs law, which is why customs and narcotics agencies cannot say Magistrate supervision is not meant for them.
The Court set out the High Court rulings that count from the restraint: Ashak Hussain (Bombay, a customs and NDPS case with near-identical facts, which said "detention in custody for interrogation" is unknown to law), T. Ramadevi (Telangana), Hanumant Nazirkar (Bombay) and Biswajit Mandal (Kerala). It disapproved the contrary trio: Aryaman Pattnayak (Orissa), Kannan (Madras) and Arun K. Thomas (Kerala). The Orissa Court had called detention "investigatory" (reasonable suspicion) and arrest "accusatory" (reasonable belief), and said a hold that outlasts a "short investigative period" becomes an arrest. The Supreme Court's reply was practical: who decides how short is short? It also noted that the Kerala single judge, instead of disagreeing with a coordinate Bench, should have asked the Chief Justice for a larger Bench.
Why the Court went back to Khatri and D.K. Basu
The Court treated this as more than drafting. The rule came out of the Bhagalpur blindings in Khatri v. State of Bihar, and D.K. Basu had warned of "screening" an arrest by not recording it or by calling it prolonged interrogation. The Court also recalled the CCTV directions in Paramvir Singh Saini, which reach the offices of the CBI, NIA, ED and NCB because they interrogate in offices as police do in stations. Unrecorded hours are where custodial abuse happens, and the 24-hour rule puts a Magistrate's eyes on the person before it can.
Counsel for the appellants also pressed Section 36 BNSS, the provision our chapter on arrest links to the D.K. Basu directions. The Court decided the case on Article 22(2) and Section 58 and made no ruling on Section 36, so do not write that Sujit Das interprets it.
Release, but not an acquittal
The conclusions are in nine numbered points, and the operative ones are these.
- The 24 hours run from the time of detention, when liberty is curtailed, not from the recorded arrest.
- If detention continues beyond 24 hours before production, the person "shall be forthwith released from custody".
- Only the journey time from the place of arrest to the court is excluded.
- The Magistrate must record the actual date and time of detention at production, check compliance, and decline remand if the detention was longer than reasonable even if within 24 hours.
For the three appellants the Court held the arrest vitiated and their continued detention beyond 2 pm on 30 September illegal. It set aside the High Court's order, directed production before the Special Court within seven days and release on bail on terms the Special Court sets. It did not quash the case or comment on the merits: the commercial-quantity charge under the NDPS Act is untouched and the trial continues. The Court also voiced reservations about Sukhwinder Singh alias Gora, the ruling the High Court had followed, which suggested Article 21 cannot be used to get past Section 37 NDPS. It noted that K.A. Najeeb and later decisions say Section 37 gives way to Article 21, and left it there because that ruling came from a coordinate Bench. The judgment is to be circulated to all Directors General of Police, Registrars General of the High Courts and State Judicial Academies.
Where the judgment stops
The Court's test is wide: the clock begins when the arresting authority detains a person on suspicion of an offence and his liberty is effectively curtailed. That leaves questions, and these three are our reading, not the Court's.
- Who is not "detained"? A witness who attends on a Section 35 BNSS notice is not the same as a suspect held by a search team. With "short investigative hold" rejected as a test, the dividing line is curtailed liberty on suspicion of an offence.
- Was the first statement taken in the gap valid? The affidavit says the men were questioned for further contraband at 2.30 pm on the 29th. The Court did not rule on statements recorded in that period.
- Re-arrest. Jaskaran Jeet Singh Deol dealt with re-arrest after a breach of Article 22. The Court cited it for the strength of the mandate but did not apply its re-arrest guidelines here; the order stops at production before the Special Court and bail.
For a Magistrate on remand duty the question changes from "when was he arrested?" to "when did he lose liberty?", and the answer goes into the order. On the investigating officer's powers in these hours see our chapter on police investigation, and on the constitutional side Article 22 and Article 21.
Three questions on the clock
1. In Sujit Das v. Union of India (2026), the Supreme Court held that the 24 hours under Article 22(2) of the Constitution begin:
- when the person's liberty is curtailed by the detaining authority, not when the arrest is formally recorded
- at the time of the arrest recorded in the arrest memo
- when the search and seizure under the NDPS Act is completed
- when the case is registered at the office of the agency
Answer
(a) The Court treated "arrested" and "detained" as one idea, rejected the buffer-zone view, and counted from the 2 pm interception. Option (c) was the Kerala High Court's view in Arun K. Thomas, which was disapproved.2. Which of the following is correct about Section 58 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023?
- It corresponds to Section 167 CrPC and lets a Magistrate authorise detention for up to 15 days
- It corresponds to Section 46 CrPC and describes how an arrest is made
- It corresponds to Section 57 CrPC and bars detention beyond what is reasonable in the circumstances, and in any case beyond 24 hours without a Magistrate's special order
- It allows the period of search and seizure formalities to be excluded from the 24 hours
Answer
(c) Section 58 BNSS carries forward Section 57 CrPC. Section 187 BNSS is the counterpart of Section 167 CrPC, Section 43 BNSS of Section 46 CrPC, and the Court held that only journey time can be excluded.3. According to Sujit Das, if a detained person is produced before a Magistrate only after the 24 hours have run out, the consequence is that:
- the person may claim only compensation and remains in custody
- the person shall be released forthwith from the detention, and the Magistrate must record the actual time of detention at production
- the Magistrate may extend the detention by recording reasons for the delay
- the prosecution against the person stands quashed