Live Bihar Judiciary 2026 mock series · 50 free questions Start now

Four years of uncommunicated C grades can end a clerk's career: Supreme Court upholds compulsory retirement in Chhattisgarh

Two Assistant Grade-III clerks said their career grades were never shown to them and that other clerks were spared. The Supreme Court asked a narrower question: was there material, and was the same yardstick used on all fourteen?

Supreme Court 2026 INSC 1205Decided 6 November 2026Manmohan & Shree Chandrashekhar, JJ.Constitution · Service Law · Administrative Law
Editorial geometric illustration in navy, teal and amber: a row of five report-card tiles, the first tall and amber, the next four short and teal, standing before a half-open door with amber light; a row of fourteen dots below, nine teal and five amber, and a rubber stamp beside a folder
One A, then four Cs, and a door held ajar by the State. Illustration: Law Mock

A government clerk in Chhattisgarh was graded A in 2013 and C in each of the next four years. He says nobody told him. In 2017 a screening committee read those grades, and on 9 October of that year an order retired him "in the public interest", with immediate effect and without notice. He and a colleague spent nine years in court arguing that a career cannot be ended on marks the employee never saw. On 6 November 2026 the Supreme Court dismissed both appeals, and in doing so drew a firm line between the law of promotion and the law of compulsory retirement.

Five of fourteen, one yardstick

Chatur Singh Dhruw and Manharan Lal Sahu began as Class-IV peons in the Legal Metrology Department at Raipur (1989 and 1993) and were promoted to Assistant Grade-III in 2012 and 2013. Both were regularised on 19 June 2015. In April 2017 the General Administration Department circulated criteria for reviewing everyone who had reached fifty years of age or twenty years of service: integrity, physical capacity, reputation and efficiency judged on the whole record, and an overall grade below "Good" (B) coupled with a check on whether the last five years showed a decline. The circular added that not every adverse remark need have been communicated.

The department's committee met on 4 September 2017 and found fourteen clerical employees in the zone. It turned each grade into a number (A+ 5, A 4, B 3, C 2, D 1), averaged them, and looked separately at the 2013 to 2017 reports for a falling trend. Five were recommended for retirement and nine were kept. Dhruw's row reads 4, 2, 2, 2, 2: an average of 2.4.

  1. 19 Jun 2015: both clerks regularised
  2. 25 Apr 2017: State circular on review of service records
  3. 4 Sep 2017: screening committee scores 14 clerks, picks 5
  4. 9 Oct 2017: retirement orders issued
  5. 23 Aug 2019 and 12 Apr 2023: Single Judge and Division Bench of the Chhattisgarh High Court decline to interfere
  6. 6 Nov 2026: Supreme Court dismisses the appeals

Why Article 311(2) never came into the room

The appellants' first argument was that the order, though dressed as retirement, was a punishment: the committee's notes spoke of "dishonesty", "unsatisfactory" work and declining output, so a disciplinary inquiry was due. That argument matters because Article 311(2) forbids dismissal, removal or reduction in rank of a civil servant without an inquiry at which he is told the charges and heard.

The Court treated the label as a question of what the order says and does. It began from the settled position that compulsory retirement is neither punitive nor stigmatic, so audi alteram partem and Article 311(2) do not apply to an order made under the service rules (para 24, citing Baikuntha Nath Das). The text of the order carried no accusation: Dhruw had completed twenty years, and he was retired under Fundamental Rule 56 and Rule 42(1)(b) of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976, in the public interest and with the State's approval. The committee's minutes were "internal deliberations" that helped the authority reach its satisfaction and did not colour the order (para 46). No inquiry was pending or contemplated, so the "device to dodge a disciplinary proceeding" argument had no record to stand on (para 47).

The commentary on Part XIV shows this is old doctrine. Article 311(2) bites where a servant suffers a penalty, such as loss of past service; compulsory retirement takes away no past service, so it is not a "penalty" (Shyam Lal v. State of U.P.). Where consequences are not penal, it is immaterial that allegations led to the decision (Parshotam Lal Dhingra). Our notes on services under the Union and the States set out the pleasure doctrine in Article 310 from which the power of compulsory retirement flows.

The Court reads the order, not the file note.

What a court may still ask

The judgment is not a charter for unreviewable retirements. Satisfaction is subjective, but it has to rest on "valid material", and a court may check that such material exists (para 25, quoting Nand Kumar Verma). Where the State has itself fixed the criteria, the court checks that they were followed (para 26, citing Amarjit Singh Ahluwalia and Ramana Dayaram Shetty). Para 27 then states the limits: the court asks whether relevant material existed, whether it was considered, and whether the conclusion is one a reasonable person could reach. It does not re-weigh the evidence as an appellate court. Para 28 lists the grounds for interference: no evidence, non-application of mind, manifest arbitrariness or perversity, and mala fides.

For a mains answer, that is the structure: subjective satisfaction, objective foundation, narrow review. The commentary adds a useful contrast. An order is liable to be quashed if it says that "better talent is available" instead of that continuance is not in the public interest (State of Sikkim v. Sonam Lama). The wording of the order, in other words, can still lose the State the case. Read this alongside the chapter on judicial review of administrative action.

Uncommunicated grades: where Dev Dutt stops

The sharpest argument was constitutional. In Dev Dutt v. Union of India, (2008) 8 SCC 725, the Supreme Court held that every ACR entry, whether poor, fair, average, good or very good, must be communicated within a reasonable time, because non-communication is arbitrary and Article 14 forbids arbitrariness. Sukhdev Singh, (2013) 9 SCC 566, approved that. The appellants said their C grades had never been shown to them, so the committee could not use them.

The Court gave two answers. First, Baikuntha Nath Das, (1992) 2 SCC 299, had already held that an order of compulsory retirement is not to be quashed merely because uncommunicated adverse remarks were also considered (para 48). Second, Dev Dutt and Sukhdev Singh were decided in the setting of promotion and career progression, where an unseen entry shapes a prospect the employee is contesting. Those principles "operate in a distinct field" and cannot be mechanically extended to compulsory retirement (para 49).

Note what the Court did not do. It did not say Dev Dutt was wrong, or that communication is unnecessary in service generally. It confined the two cases by subject matter. The commentary states Dev Dutt in its wide form (Article 14 requires every ACR entry to be communicated) and, separately, the Baikuntha rule on compulsory retirement. After this judgment the two are read together: the first for promotion-type consequences, the second for retirement in the public interest.

QuestionPromotion, confirmation, upgradingCompulsory retirement
Must every ACR entry be communicated?Yes, on Dev Dutt and Sukhdev SinghNo; retirement is not quashed on that ground alone (Baikuntha)
Is Article 311(2) engaged?Not by the entry itselfNo, because the order is not punishment
Is a hearing required before the decision?The entry may be challenged by representationNo; audi alteram partem does not apply
What does the court examine?Fairness of the process and the entryExistence of material, application of mind, bona fides
Asked before: Odisha Judiciary Mains 2015 asked: "What are the restrictions on the Power of President or Governor to dismiss a Government Servant under Article 311 of the Constitution? Discuss." The answer for 2026 needs one more paragraph: Article 311 restricts dismissal, removal and reduction in rank, and compulsory retirement without a penal element stays outside it, as Chatur Singh Dhruw restates.

Promotion cleans the past, not the future

Baikuntha Nath Das says that if an employee is promoted despite adverse remarks, the remarks lose their sting, more so where promotion is by merit. The appellants had been promoted and regularised and said so. The Court limited the principle to entries that pre-date the promotion and are presumed to have been overlooked by the promoting authority (para 39). Dhruw had been promoted on 14 March 2013 and Sahu on 3 October 2012, so every grade from 2013 to 2017 related to the promoted post. A promotion cannot, the Court said, neutralise entries recorded after it.

Regularisation did even less. It confers substantive status in the post already held and is not a comparative assessment of merit, so it cannot be read as an endorsement of the employee's future efficiency (para 43).

The negative equality argument, and the fourteen-row table

The appellants also argued discrimination under Article 14, relying on an order of 9 October 2025 in which the Court had asked the Principal Secretary to affirm by affidavit that no similarly placed employee had been left out. The State answered with the fourteen-row table. The Court did two things with it.

First, in principle, an employee cannot defeat a compulsory retirement merely by pointing to a comparable colleague who was kept. Evaluating utility, integrity and efficiency is an individual exercise. Equality under Article 14 is "a positive concept" and does not allow a claim of negative equality, since a lapse in one case cannot be a basis for repeating it (para 29, citing Union of India v. M.K. Sarkar and Basawaraj). Our chapter on the right to equality covers the positive and negative sides of Article 14.

Second, "in any event", the Court held on the facts that the same parameters were applied to everyone. It noted that none of the nine retained clerks showed the combination of three factors: an overall assessment below B, sustained C gradings across 2013 to 2017 with no improvement, and adverse remarks on efficiency (para 34). Three other employees, treated alike, were retired along with the appellants.

Read that against the table itself. Several retained clerks also averaged under 3.0 (2.6 and 2.8), while Ramlal Sarute, retired, averaged 2.4, the same as Dhruw. The Court did not rest on the average alone but on the three factors together, and on the Committee, not a court, forming the view.

Where this fits in the Chhattisgarh exam

CG Judiciary Prelims 2016 tested Article 14 in plain form, asking what it provides to all persons; the answer is equality before law and equal protection of the law. A mains problem on a retirement dispute would reward four points: the status of the order (not punishment), the reviewable grounds, the Dev Dutt contrast, and the refusal of negative equality. The notes on reasoned decisions and speaking orders help with the stigma question, since an order that records only the rule and the public interest says nothing capable of casting a stain.

Questions the judgment leaves alone

  • It does not say whether Dev Dutt would assist an employee whose uncommunicated entries were used for promotion denial and then for retirement in one chain of events. It decides the case before it.
  • The order recorded that the clerks had completed twenty years of service and were retired "without giving you notice". The judgment does not discuss notice or pay in lieu. The commentary records the rule that the only right of the servant is to three months' pay and allowances in lieu of notice (State of A.P. v. T.K. Seshadri), a point not argued here.
  • The Court does not explain how many "C" years are enough. The test it applied is overall record below B plus a recent decline, not a fixed number of low gradings.

For practice on service law and the Constitution, try the Chhattisgarh Judiciary mock tests.

1. In Chatur Singh Dhruw v. State of Chhattisgarh (2026), the Supreme Court refused to apply Article 311(2) to the retirement orders because:

  1. the clerks held only temporary posts
  2. the clerks had consented to retirement after twenty years
  3. Article 311 does not cover Class-III employees
  4. compulsory retirement under the service rules, in the public interest and without stigma, is not punishment
Answer

(d). The orders merely recorded retirement in the public interest under FR 56 and Rule 42(1)(b), and the committee's internal minutes did not make them stigmatic. Options (a) to (c) have no basis in the judgment: both clerks were regularised, and Article 311 protects civil servants generally.

2. A civil servant challenges a compulsory retirement order on the ground that adverse ACR grades used against him were never communicated, relying on Dev Dutt. On this ruling:

  1. the order must be quashed, because every entry must be communicated before it is relied on
  2. the order is not liable to be quashed on that ground alone, as Dev Dutt and Sukhdev Singh belong to promotion and career progression
  3. the order is valid only if the employee is first given a hearing under Article 311(2)
  4. the order is valid only if the communicated entries alone show unsuitability
Answer

(b). The Court followed Baikuntha Nath Das and held that Dev Dutt and Sukhdev Singh operate in a distinct field. Judicial review remains for want of material, non-application of mind, arbitrariness or mala fides.

3. The appellants argued that some similarly placed clerks were kept in service. Which answer best states the Supreme Court's treatment of this argument?

  1. It succeeds, because Article 14 requires every similarly placed employee to be retired
  2. It succeeds unless the State proves the retirement was punitive
  3. It fails, because Article 14 is a positive concept that does not support negative equality, and in any case the same parameters were applied to all fourteen
  4. It fails only because the clerks did not file a writ for reinstatement
Answer

(c). Article 14 does not allow an employee to claim the benefit of a lapse in another's case. The Court also found, on the committee's record, that the criteria were applied uniformly.

Source: Supreme Court of India, Chatur Singh Dhruw v. The State of Chhattisgarh & Ors., Civil Appeals arising out of SLP(C) Nos. 24392 and 25201 of 2023, 2026 INSC 1205, judgment of Manmohan J. dated 6 November 2026. This explainer is for exam preparation and is not legal advice.

Also in the 10 November 2026 edition

Delhi High Court A matching blood group on a sword and a shirt, and a recovery nobody could prove: Delhi High Court acquits two of a 1998 murder Bombay High Court Charge-framing is not the lighter test: why Bombay HC set aside Sachin Waze's UAPA bail 59 days after charges
Law Mock is an independent preparation resource and is not affiliated with any High Court, Public Service Commission, or government body. All exam information is sourced from official notifications and is updated periodically.