The Bhakra-Nangal and Beas projects stand on land that now lies in Himachal Pradesh, yet for decades most of their power went to Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and Chandigarh. Himachal sued in 1996 under Article 131 and won a 7.19% share on 27 September 2011. On 6 November 2026 the Supreme Court, speaking through Surya Kant CJI, did what the Union of India and three rounds of mediation could not. It fixed 13,066 million units of arrears, set off Himachal's capital-cost liability against them, and ordered the balance supplied over twenty winters.
A decree already made: why November 2026 was not a rehearing
The Court began by fencing the exercise. Paragraph 30 says the present exercise "is not intended to reopen" the 2011 decree and is "in the nature of execution proceedings". That sentence decides how the whole judgment should be read. What follows is a table of what had been settled and what this ruling added.
| Question | Settled on 27 Sept 2011 | Settled on 6 Nov 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Is there a legal right? | Yes: section 78(1) of the Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966 itself gave one, enforceable under Article 131 | Not reopened |
| Size of the share | 7.19% of composite Punjab's power: 6.095% of Bhakra-Nangal, 5.752% of Beas Unit I, 2.984% of Beas Unit II | Not reopened |
| Who owes it | Punjab and Haryana (51.8% and 37.51%), with Chandigarh's 3.5% met out of their shares; not Rajasthan | Split between them at 58:42 (Bhakra) and 60:40 (Beas), the proportions in which they actually drew power |
| 12% "home state" free power | Refused: no right independent of the Constitution, and the 1985 Cabinet decision was only policy | Not reopened |
| How much, valued how, paid how | Left to the Union of India to compute | 13,066 MU, set off, supplied in kind over 20 lean seasons |
The Union's 2013 affidavit computed a shortfall of 13,066 million units (MU) for 1 November 1966 to October 2011. Himachal accepted it; Punjab and Haryana did not. The Union could compute but could not bind two States that disputed its arithmetic. Only the Court could.
Section 78: a two-year clock that never ran
The root of the dispute is a gap in the 1966 Act. Under section 78(1), the rights and liabilities of the old Punjab in the two projects pass to the successor States "in such proportion as may be fixed" by agreement after consulting the Centre, or, if there is no agreement within two years of the appointed day, as the Centre "may by order determine". The proviso lets a later agreement vary the Centre's order. The appointed day was 1 November 1966, so the Centre's deadline lapsed in 1968 without any order. Power was shared on an ad hoc basis for decades: Himachal received 2.5% of the Bhakra share, a 15 MW allocation from Beas Unit I, and nothing from Unit II.
This is why the 2011 Court found that Himachal's allocations had only ever been ad hoc, so limitation never began (Article 131 prescribes none anyway). Himachal's claim rested on the population transferred to it under section 5 of the Act, and the Court treated the 1967 summary record as "tentative" and not the final agreement that section 78 contemplates.
Article 131: the three gates and the Article 262 door
The constitutional commentary in our library breaks Article 131 into conditions that this suit met in 2011, and the 2026 order proceeds on them.
- The parties. Only the Union and States may be parties. Citing State of Bihar v. Union of India (AIR 1970), the commentary says private bodies cannot be joined and the Article 12 definition of "State" does not apply. Here the defendants were the Union, Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and Chandigarh. The extract does not show the Court explaining how a Union Territory fits; Chandigarh's 3.5% was met out of Punjab's and Haryana's shares.
- A legal right. The dispute must turn on a question "on which the existence or extent of a legal right depends". That is why Himachal won 7.19% and lost the 12% home-state claim: section 78 is statute, while the 1985 Cabinet decision was policy.
- A constitutional capacity. The books say Article 131 covers disputes between governments in that capacity, not a State suing as a trader. A statutory power-sharing right is the former.
The fourth condition is Article 262. Article 131 is "subject to the provisions of this Constitution", and Article 262(2) lets Parliament oust every court, including the Supreme Court, from inter-State river water disputes. Parliament did so in section 11 of the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956. The Court's answer in 2011 was that a suit about the sharing of power was not a dispute about the use of the waters, so the bar did not apply. Rajasthan also objected that it could not be sued without Central consent under sections 86 and 87-B CPC; the 2011 result was that the right ran against Punjab, Haryana, Chandigarh and the Union, but not Rajasthan, which was never part of composite Punjab.
Three trips to the Attorney General, and why mediation did not end it
After the 2011 decree the Court asked the Attorney General's office to help settle the figures three times: on 7 August 2014 (report 16 January 2015), with talks in November 2017, and from 11 September 2024. Meetings in December 2024 showed "some progress", and on 4 February 2025 the parties got a "last opportunity". The Attorney General then proposed a cashless framework, placed before the Court on 30 July and 20 August 2026. Himachal and Haryana agreed in principle; Punjab objected on the 1.2 lakh units a day Himachal separately received, the rate for converting capital cost, and the length of the schedule.
Mediation was not the source of the decree. Paragraph 29 says "the responsibility has accordingly devolved upon this Court" to settle the matter finally. The Court did not record a compromise or treat Punjab's reluctance as a veto; it adopted the Attorney General's framework as its own decision and thanked him in paragraph 42 for his "good offices". For a mains answer: a consent decree binds because parties agreed, while this order binds because the Court decided. Our CPC commentary notes that Order XXVII rule 5B casts a duty on a court, in a suit against the Government, to help the parties settle; the judgment does not cite it.
Why each of Punjab's three objections failed
The contentions were "vague and superficial" and amounted to an attempt "to relitigate issues already settled" by the 2011 decree.
The 1.2 lakh units a day had "already been considered and accounted for" in the capital-cost figure (paragraph 33). Punjab's wish to convert that cost at today's 79-paise operation-and-maintenance rate, which would have left about 5,768 MU due, was "inaccurate and misleading": the arrears relate to an earlier period and "cannot be computed at a rate that prevails today". On duration, Punjab's only ground was that an earlier Union note had mentioned thirty years, while Haryana accepted fifteen. The Court instead stretched the schedule to twenty years "with a view to easing the burden on the Defendant States".
The operative arithmetic, in the Court's own order
- Arrears: 13,066 MU, from Punjab and Haryana, 58:42 for Bhakra-Nangal and 60:40 for Beas, over 20 lean seasons (October to March), at 653 MU a year.
- Himachal's liability: 7.19% of the capital cost, the unreimbursed loan servicing by Punjab and Haryana since 1966-67: Rs 420.77 crore (Punjab Rs 249.23 crore, Haryana Rs 171.55 crore).
- Set-off: energy valued at Rs 3.85 a unit, so about 1,093 MU is cancelled against that liability.
- Balance: about 11,973 MU, at about 598 MU a year over 20 lean seasons, with Himachal paying the BBMB charges for the year in which each tranche arrives. No cash changes hands.
Execution without attachment: what is unusual here
Ordinary execution works through section 51 CPC: delivery of property, attachment and sale, arrest and detention, or a receiver. None suits a debt payable in electricity. The judgment does not name its source of power, but the commentary on Article 131 records that after State of Rajasthan v. Union of India (AIR 1977), Article 142(1) lets the Court grant whatever relief an Article 131 suit needs and not merely a declaration, as State of Bihar had first held.
Two further points. The Union computed but was not the judgment-debtor: paragraph 5.26 notes that clause (iii) of the 2011 decree wrongly refers to "Defendant Nos. 3 and 4", while clauses (i) and (iv) bind Punjab and Haryana (Nos. 2 and 3), and later proceedings treated those two as debtors. And section 82 CPC bars execution against the Union or a State until the decree has stayed unsatisfied for three months; our commentary adds that limitation does not run before that. The judgment does not mention it.
Paragraph 43 gives the order its force: the directions "are binding and are required to be acted upon without reservation", and a decree-holder's expectation "cannot be rendered fruitless by reason of the unwillingness or recalcitrance of a Judgment Debtor". The commentary supplies a parallel: when Punjab legislated in 2004 to nullify a Supreme Court decree in a suit by Haryana under Article 131, the Court held (Re Punjab Termination of Agreement Act, 2004, 2017) that the State could not discharge itself, and, citing State of Tamil Nadu v. State of Kerala (2014), that a law deciding a federal dispute undoes the Article 131 and 262 machinery. A decree under Article 131 cannot be avoided by a statute or by delay.
What the judgment leaves open
- Paragraph 41(a) and 41(e) give two annual figures, 653 MU on the gross arrears and about 598 MU after the set-off. The text reads as if 598 MU is the working figure, since direction (f) calls for a cashless settlement "in the manner set out hereinabove"; read both before quoting either.
- Himachal's wider claims, including losses from submergence of about 27,869 acres at Bhakra and over 65,050 acres at Beas, forest loss and Rs 1,745 crore of open-market purchases, are described in the submissions but the Court does not rule on them, and it calls the matter closed.
- How a missed tranche would be enforced is not spelt out beyond paragraph 43.
Where this fits in the exams
Revise three things: Article 131 needs a legal right between governments; Article 262 and the 1956 Act remove only water disputes; and an Article 131 decree can be executed by the Court itself, not only by the Code. See our union judiciary chapter, suits by or against the Government and execution: general principles.
Three questions on Article 131 and the 2026 order
1. Which of the following statements about the Supreme Court's original jurisdiction under Article 131 is correct?
- A private company may be joined with a State as a co-plaintiff if the dispute arises from the same facts
- A statutory corporation is a "State" for Article 131 because of the wide definition in Article 12
- It extends to a dispute between two departments of the same Government
- It applies only where the dispute involves a question on which the existence or extent of a legal right depends
Answer
(d) That is the text of the Article. Private parties cannot be joined and the Article 12 definition of "State" does not apply to it (State of Bihar v. Union of India, as recorded in the commentary), and a dispute between two departments of one government is not a dispute between constituent units.2. In State of Himachal Pradesh v. Union of India (2026), the Supreme Court described its exercise after the 2011 decree as:
- a fresh adjudication that re-examined the 7.19% share
- in the nature of execution proceedings that did not reopen matters decided in 2011
- a consent decree recording a settlement among all the States
- a reference to a tribunal under the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956
Answer
(b) Paragraph 30 says the exercise is not meant to reopen the 2011 decree and is in the nature of execution proceedings. Punjab did not consent, and the 1956 Act was relevant only to the Article 262 bar discussed in 2011.3. Under the Court's directions, Himachal Pradesh's capital-cost liability of Rs 420.77 crore is adjusted against the energy arrears by valuing energy at Rs 3.85 a unit. The adjustment is approximately:
- 5,768 million units
- 871 million units
- 1,093 million units
- 11,973 million units